The loudness of the amp is entirely determined by the last stage, i.e. the EL84 and to some degree on its working parameters (load impedance, screen voltage, anode voltage). If You reduce gain You need a higher input voltage to achieve the maximum power. On this level of argumentation it will not matter how the gain is reduced - by tubes with lower gain, by voltage dividers or by NFB (just to name some examples).
One simple and cheap method to reduce gain might be the removal of *all* cathode capacitances. This will add local NFB to each stage and, as a drawback, increased output resistance of that stage. Unfortunately we do not know what You mean by "all the mods" - some of the proposed mods might be contradicting.
BTW: changing tubes was the first of my modifications. Later on i restored the original tubes.
Beate